Find An Insurance Agent To Assist With Your Medicare Needs

Our team of trained insurance specialists spread across the states we service to provide local, personalized service that helps to cut the confusion and get you the policy you need quickly and affordably.

Get started by browsing through our network of agents below

Rick Frommling

Rick Frommling

(Managing Partner)

Rick grew up in Southwest Ohio and graduated from Little Miami High School in 1980. He started in the insurance industry in 1985 after a career in the grocery business was not providing him with a great enough opportunity. In the 35 years since, Rick has been passionate about providing clients with top tier service and agents with the support they need to excel in their careers. He currently lives in Lebanon, OH with his wife, Meg where they raised their 8 children.

Joe Frommling

Joe Frommling

(Partner)

Joe was born and raised in Lebanon, Ohio where he graduated from Lebanon High School in 2008. Since then he attended the University of Kentucky studying Political Science and working as a Field Coordinator with the Republican Party of Kentucky in 2010. Joe then served five years as an infantryman in the United States Marine Corps. After the Marine Corps, he began offering his services throughout the Commonwealth of Kentucky, specializing in Medicare products. Joe serves as our Medicare lines coordinator and trainer. After establishing an office in Lexington, Joe now lives in the Northern Kentucky area with his wife, Amanda, and children Olivia, Nora, Otto, and Rocco.

Graham Morgan

Graham Morgan

(Partner)

Graham lives in Lebanon Ohio with his wife Hilary and three kids Kelton, Savanah and Bennett. While earning a B.S. in exercise physiology at Wilmington College he also competed on the track team. He also coaches track for the local high school. Since college he gained experience in direct sales and medical sales before joining 5 Star 3 years ago. He says this about his time with us, “This is truly a place where the good guy wins. I serve others and get rewarded for that. I feel like it’s the best shot for an average guy like me to live an extraordinary life.

Matt Suter

Matt Suter

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Matt is from Mason, Ohio and graduated from the University of Dayton (’85) BSBA in Systems Analysis and Xavier University MBA (’90). Matt came to us in 2020 after a 30 year career as a Section Manager at Procter & Gamble where he retired. He loves helping individuals, families and small businesses make sound insurance decisions. His focus is on educating his clients and insuring their peace of mind. After working 30 years in corporate America as an IT professional, “it is refreshing to make a positive impact one client at a time.” Matt lives in Southwest Ohio with his wife Kelly and has 4 children; Holly (Chicago), Thomas (Columbus), Katie (Dallas), Patrick (Miami University) and dog, Crosley.

Chris Beisner

Chris Beisner

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Chris is a resident of Warren County Ohio and has been a resident of Ohio his entire life. He enjoys the slow country life with his wife and two amazing children. He earned a B.S. in Accounting at Urbana University and went on to work for 5 years as an Assistant Auditor for the State of Ohio Auditors Office. After that, Chris moved into law enforcement for nearly 8 years and left that career to give more time to God and family. He has been with the company for over a year now and no other job has compared to this in terms of flexibility and fulfillment. He is passionate about helping people through this stage of life change and allowing them to rest assured that their needs are taken care of so they can focus on what really matters. Chris was the winner of the 2020 Rookie of the Year Award given to the highest producing first-year agent.

Carolin Cassio

Carolin Cassio

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Carolin grew up in New Vienna, Ohio and has stayed in Southwest Ohio. She came to us after working as a cosmetologist because she is passionate about getting to know people and providing professional service to her clients. Carolin currently lives in Kings Mills with her husband Irv and 3 sons.

Jason Cassio

Jason Cassio

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Jason is originally from Kings Mills but lives in Cincinnati where he is a full-time student at the University of Cincinnati. He loves his role with 5 Star because “I feel like I am genuinely making a difference in the lives of the people I get the opportunity to serve.

Devin Monroe

Devin Monroe

(Agent – Dayton)

Devin Monroe was born in Atlanta, Georgia and started with the company in 2021 focusing on Northwest Dayton. Devin graduated from Kent State University majoring in Business Administration and minoring in Marketing and Economics while being a member of the Football and Track teams. He enjoys meeting new people every day and having a chance to help them in a meaningful way while being part of a great team. Devin currently resides in Middletown.

John Cookson

John Cookson

(Agent – Tampa)

John grew up in Wilmington, North Carolina and left home to work for Don Cesar Hotel in St Pete Beach, Florida. He joined the company in 2019 and established an office in Tampa where he currently works. “This company has given me the most rewarding opportunity I have ever had. I am able to give my family a good life while doing a job in which I can serve my clients with excellence. It has felt like more of a journey than a job. John lives in St Petersburg with his wife, Ashley and children, Juliette and John-Avery.

Tim Frommling

Tim Frommling

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Tim was born and raised in Lebanon, Ohio. After high school, he joined the company as part of our expansion team into Central and Eastern Kentucky. In 2018, he took over retail partnerships in Kentucky with CVS and Walmart pharmacies. Tim sees his each of his clients as family and values the relationship he has with each one of them.

Nicole Torregrossa

Nicole Bjorndahl

(Agent – Baton Rouge)

Nicole was born in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. She has been with the company since 2018, and in 2019, established an office the greater Baton Rouge area. Nicole graduated in 2014 with a BA in Religious and Pastoral studies, and a specialization in communication in order to pursue missionary work. She has always been passionate about reaching out to those in need. After graduating from college, Nicole ceased full time mission work and moved back to Louisiana. For the next five years, she was employed by Apple Inc. in sales and staff training. Her passion for helping people has led to skills that have guided her current career. Nicole now enjoys the puzzle of fitting every unique person with their complete healthcare solution, as well as the fulfillment of knowing that she is helping people in a vulnerable and important moment in their lives.

Josiah Steele

Josiah Steele

(Agent – Cincinnati)

Josiah was born and raised in Morrow, Ohio and graduated from Little Miami High School in 2019. In 2021 he worked with the mission organization, Youth With A Mission, serving the homeless and those struggling with addiction. He is dedicated to quality customer service and making sure his clients are seen and cared for as if they were his own family. His main passion in life is to spread the gospel and make sure the Kingdom of God is known on earth.

Kim Pittl

Kim Pittl

(Agent – Dayton)

Kim is from Huber Heights, Ohio and currently resides in Springboro with her husband and 5 children. In 1996, she graduated from Wright State University with a degree in Sociology, Psychology and a concentration in Law Enforcement. Her passion for people led her to get certified in many different areas of community health including crisis intervention, Alzheimer’s, mental health & negotiations. After a 30 year career in public service, she decided to pursue a career in the Medicare and Health field. Her passion is to help people in the community grow gracefully into their retirement age with better physical and mental health, adding not only years but value to their lives. She believes “as one grows older physically, they should never stop growing mentally or spiritually.

Katie Weimer

Katie Weimer

(Agent – Dayton)

Katie grew up in Lebanon, Ohio and was a graduate of Springboro High School. She went on to graduate with a Bachelors of Specialized Studies in Early Childhood development and Family Communication from Ohio University. After living in Florida and Georgia while her husband served in the United States Air Force, and raising their 6 kids, they decided it was time to settle back in Ohio to give the kids a chance to finish growing up with family close by. Katie decided to join her family business because she has a passion for serving and helping others. Her passion is specifically driven towards working with other military families and veterans as they transition to Medicare. Her experience as a teacher has led her to being able to educate others on their healthcare choices that are best suited to each individual client.

James Burton

James Burton

(Agent – Dayton)

James was raised in Clarksville, Ohio graduating from Clinton Massie in 2004. James went on to earn a BS in Sports Management from Bowling Green State University (‘08) and a MS in Sport and Recreation Management from Indiana State University (‘11). After moving to Fort Worth, Texas to briefly work in his field of study, James returned to Ohio in 2013 to attend the police academy and spent the next 10 years serving his community in law enforcement. The three principal foundations of James’ life are Faith/Family/Friends and he chose to leave law enforcement so he could focus more on those foundational pillars. James enjoys anything that involves sports, being outdoors, or country living. He is the proud father to Lucy and Brooklynn whom he adores. James is passionate about building lasting relationships and, in doing so, providing his clients with the service and respect they deserve.

James Lesniewski

James Lesniewski

(Agent – Northern Kentucky)

James is originally from Crystal Lake, IL. He studied Theology and Business from Ave Maria University, where he also played baseball. Since graduation he has been running his own online retail business in Northern Kentucky. In 2023, James joined our Kentucky team specializing in Medicare products for those that are turning 65. He finds joy in being able to speak with and getting to know members of the community. He currently resides in Burlington and is blessed by God with a wife and four children.

Andrew Lesniewski

Andrew Lesniewski

(Agent – Milwaukee)

Andrew grew up in Spring Grove, IL. He earned his undergraduate from Ave Maria University in 2020 where he was a member of the baseball team. Andrew came into the business with his brother, James, in 2023 because he wanted to make a difference in the lives of his clients by advising them on their healthcare journey. He currently resides in Milwaukee where he services the Greater Milwaukee area and Northern Illinois.